New York City
Columbus Crew
New York City vs Columbus Crew Prediction
Why we picked this for New York City vs Columbus Crew
Our pick for New York City vs Columbus Crew in Major League Soccer is Over 2.5 goals, with 56% confidence. Recent form: 2 of New York City's last 5 games went over 2.5 goals (3.2 goals per game in total), against 3 of 5 for Columbus Crew (3.0 per game). Recent form is split here (5 of 10 games went over 2.5), so it doesn't settle the call on its own.
Previous meetings agree, with 3 of the last 5 head-to-heads ending over 2.5. The 56% confidence reflects a real but modest lean in the recent numbers. The match ended 3-0, so Over 2.5 landed.
Recommended bookmakers
Partners offering strong markets for over/under betting. 18+, terms apply.
Last 5 matches, each side
Most recent match first. Tag shows whether that match went over or under 2.5 total goals.
Last 5 meetings
New York City vs Columbus Crew, most recent first.
| Date | Home | Away | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 18, 2025 | New York City | Columbus Crew | 3-2 | Over 2.5✓ |
| Mar 23, 2025 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 0-0 | Under 2.5✕ |
| Sep 01, 2024 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 4-2 | Over 2.5✓ |
| Aug 18, 2024 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 1-1 | Under 2.5✕ |
| Jun 15, 2024 | New York City | Columbus Crew | 2-3 | Over 2.5✓ |