Columbus Crew
New York City
Columbus Crew vs New York City Prediction
Why we picked this for Columbus Crew vs New York City
Our pick for Columbus Crew vs New York City in Major League Soccer is Over 2.5 goals, with 91% confidence. Recent form: 3 of Columbus Crew's last 5 games went over 2.5 goals (3.4 goals per game in total), against 2 of 5 for New York City (2.2 per game). Form on its own doesn't settle this one: 5 of the 10 recent games went over 2.5, which is worth keeping in mind before backing Over 2.5.
Previous meetings agree, with 3 of the last 5 head-to-heads ending over 2.5. At 91%, most of the recent evidence lands on this side of the line, which makes it one of our stronger calls. Final score: 1-2. The pick won.
Recommended bookmakers
Partners offering strong markets for over/under betting. 18+, terms apply.
Last 5 matches, each side
Most recent match first. Tag shows whether that match went over or under 2.5 total goals.
Last 5 meetings
Columbus Crew vs New York City, most recent first.
| Date | Home | Away | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 10, 2026 | New York City | Columbus Crew | 3-0 | Over 2.5✓ |
| Sep 18, 2025 | New York City | Columbus Crew | 3-2 | Over 2.5✓ |
| Mar 23, 2025 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 0-0 | Under 2.5✕ |
| Sep 01, 2024 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 4-2 | Over 2.5✓ |
| Aug 18, 2024 | Columbus Crew | New York City | 1-1 | Under 2.5✕ |