Cincinnati
New York City
Cincinnati vs New York City Prediction
Why we picked this for Cincinnati vs New York City
Over 3.5 goals is an analyst pick for Cincinnati vs New York City (Major League Soccer): it goes against the recent numbers below, so it carries no confidence figure. In their last 5 matches, Cincinnati's games produced 3.4 goals on average, 2 of them over 3.5. New York City's games averaged 3.0, with 1 of 5 over the line. The recent numbers point the other way: only 3 of the 10 recent games of these two teams went over 3.5. Recent results can mislead when the teams have been playing very different opposition (another league, much stronger or much weaker sides), and here the analyst expects this match to play differently.
The head-to-head doesn't back it either: only 2 of their last 5 meetings finished over 3.5 goals. Treat it as a judgement call rather than a pick backed by the numbers. The match ended 2-1, so Over 3.5 didn't come in.
Recommended bookmakers
Partners offering strong markets for over/under betting. 18+, terms apply.
Last 5 matches, each side
Most recent match first. Tag shows whether that match went over or under 3.5 total goals.
Last 5 meetings
Cincinnati vs New York City, most recent first.
| Date | Home | Away | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2026 | New York City | Cincinnati | 4-4 | Over 3.5✓ |
| Aug 24, 2025 | Cincinnati | New York City | 0-1 | Under 3.5✕ |
| May 04, 2025 | New York City | Cincinnati | 1-0 | Under 3.5✕ |
| Nov 09, 2024 | Cincinnati | New York City | 0-1 | Under 3.5✕ |
| Nov 02, 2024 | New York City | Cincinnati | 3-1 | Over 3.5✓ |


