Home/USA Tips/New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC
Major League SoccerSunday, 18 October 2026 · Kick-off 00:30 UTC
NEW

New York Red Bulls

VS
TOR

Toronto FC

New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC Prediction

Under3.5 goals
72% confidence
Best odds 1.89 @ BetWinnerBet now @ 1.89 →

Why we picked this for New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC

For this Major League Soccer fixture we go with Under 3.5 goals for New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC, at 72% confidence. In their last 5 matches, New York Red Bulls's games produced 2.6 goals on average, 1 of them over 3.5. Toronto FC's games averaged 3.6, with 2 of 5 over the line. Current form is what points us towards Under 3.5.

History between the two sides fits the pick too: 4 of 5 recent meetings went under 3.5. A confidence of 72% means the recent numbers clearly point to Under 3.5.

How we make our predictions →

Advertisement

Recommended bookmakers

Partners offering strong markets for over/under betting. 18+, terms apply.

1xbet
Claim bonus →
New customers only. 18+. T&Cs apply.
22bet
Claim bonus →
New customers only. 18+. T&Cs apply.
GG.bet
Claim bonus →
New customers only. 18+. T&Cs apply.
2.6
avg goals, New York Red Bulls last 5
3.6
avg goals, Toronto FC last 5
20%
last 5 H2H went over 3.5
3 / 10
combined form matches over

Last 5 matches, each side

Most recent match first. Tag shows whether that match went over or under 3.5 total goals.

New York Red Bulls
DC United 2-1 New York Red Bulls
Oct 15, 2026
Under 3.5✓
New York Red Bulls 4-1 San Diego
Oct 11, 2026
Over 3.5✕
New York Red Bulls 0-3 St. Louis City
Oct 01, 2026
Under 3.5✓
New York City 0-1 New York Red Bulls
Sep 19, 2026
Under 3.5✓
Columbus Crew 0-1 New York Red Bulls
Sep 13, 2026
Under 3.5✓
Toronto FC
Toronto FC 3-3 Orlando City
Oct 15, 2026
Over 3.5✕
Toronto FC 2-1 Montreal Impact
Oct 10, 2026
Under 3.5✓
Nashville 2-0 Toronto FC
Sep 27, 2026
Under 3.5✓
St. Louis City 3-1 Toronto FC
Sep 20, 2026
Over 3.5✕
Orlando City 3-0 Toronto FC
Sep 13, 2026
Under 3.5✓

Last 5 meetings

New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC, most recent first.

DateHomeAwayScoreResult
Mar 14, 2026Toronto FCNew York Red Bulls1-1
Under 3.5✓
Jun 26, 2025Toronto FCNew York Red Bulls1-1
Under 3.5✓
Mar 23, 2025New York Red BullsToronto FC2-1
Under 3.5✓
Oct 03, 2024Toronto FCNew York Red Bulls1-4
Over 3.5✕
Jul 28, 2024New York Red BullsToronto FC0-0
Under 3.5✓

Live Betting & Streaming Active — Don't miss a single second! Track every shift in momentum and place your live bets on New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC in real-time on mobile, tablet, or desktop.

Unlock Live Stream on BetWinner →